disagreement's unpracticed art
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c2b3f/c2b3f2187ff2a36feacc7896eb50d4c0597f5edb" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f18ea/f18ea5a0cd94363dd558a434c6850fa4b11c1238" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e7f4b/e7f4bfb3671b259deea79512e098e5882a0ae594" alt=""
but despite the sun, fun, and the exquisite company of my best travel buddy, a not especially interesting conversation about whether fat black women in popular culture were a result of historical "mammy" stereotypes or black mens appreciation for fuller figures exposed the travel fatigue that sets in after 2 wks of 24/7 cohabitation. that conversation was my breaking point after 2 wks of feeling like the only person who has anger about race. 2 wks of generally respectful questions from almost exclusively white folks was feeling like a deluge of condescending skepticism.
since i have anger and my thoughts on race and identity are mildly radical, i should be accustomed to discussing these issues with a skeptical (mostly white) public. i should have sufficient experience crafting effective retorts and persuading others to consider my point of view. most conversations are topical with well-worn arguments on "both" sides, so only a little study would be necessary. yet like most of us, ive instead spent my time cultivating a philosophical faction of like-minded folks. my real frustration with krissy was my inability to articulately respond to her reasonable questions.
back to flattery. during conversation its fun to have people nod and praise you via their agreement. we have become so used to it that its amusing to see how defensive folks get when someone disagrees. even disagreement is prefaced with sugary sweet affirmation to prep us for the offense of disagreement.
its often lamented of late how divided our society is. we seem cleanly cut into ridiculous binaries of red state/blue state, black/white, male/female, gay/straight, right/wrong, without acknowledging the vast middle ground that most of us occupy. yet our self-segregation affirms these extreme points of view, rejects nuance, and exacerbates feelings of difference. were left with an "us/them" mentality, and without a middle ground to tred upon, avoid confrontation and have nowhere to meet anyway. i hope to improve my ability to disagree artfullly... to reclaim some middle ground and practice persuasion.
Labels: miami, race, travel, turks and caicos